Page 3 of 8
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:04 PM
by jhh925
toddness wrote:I'd be really surprised if the reserve is higher than the current 33K (at the time i started writing this).
BaT is notorious for setting low reserves. One of the interesting aspects of BaT is if a car does not meet the reserve, they reserve the right to buy the car at the reserve.
Wild. I didn't know that. Regardless, my guess on the reserve was $38,000. It's up to $38,500 presently, so ... who knows. Looks to be three serious bidders - good news for seller!
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:06 PM
by hugh1850
Boom! over $40K
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:28 PM
by Mike W.
All that and it's probably got crappy A/C. They mentioned a new compressor and 134a conversion, but nothing about a condenser upgrade. Oh well, out of my price range anyway, regardless of how nice it looks.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:42 PM
by wkohler
So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:44 PM
by hugh1850
wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
Exactly. This should put that argument to rest. Over 30K views and 787 watchers.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:54 PM
by domenico
Wow 50K. This makes all of EAG's 88 M5's worth 100k now. Unreal I should have finished my car off and sold it for 60k (LOL).
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 4:57 PM
by Karl Grau
wkohler wrote:BaT was the right choice for listing this car
The Greeks knew it. The Carthaginians knew it. Now George knows it.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 5:03 PM
by wkohler
Karl Grau wrote:wkohler wrote:BaT was the right choice for listing this car
The Greeks knew it. The Carthaginians knew it. Now George knows it.
We can only hope.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 5:30 PM
by tig
Anyone here thinks THEIR car will come close to commanding this sort of value is suffering from what we call confirmation bias.
Get over it. This is a one time affair.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 5:49 PM
by sail_or_drive
While I don't disagree that there are many, if any, non-M5 cars will command that kind of value, I am inspired to get out the rags, brushes, and q-tips when working on my own admittedly pedestrian daily drivers. The attention to detail is what made this car in my eyes. Thanks to OC Coupe and the seller for setting the bar high.
On another note, Maytag or Vlad would command at least a 50% premium just from CEK's care and attention to detail, IMO. I think it's the same with many other cars on the board.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 6:16 PM
by OcCoupe
I hope this gives people a little boost of enthusiasm. We all love these cars for very good reasons. Other people that may not have considered the e28 5 years ago are now recognizing how great they really are. Now there's a little payoff for our passions. Now go give your e28 a little love.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 6:20 PM
by ahab
Karl Grau wrote:wkohler wrote:BaT was the right choice for listing this car
The Greeks knew it. The Carthaginians knew it. Now George knows it.
Hahaha
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 6:22 PM
by tig
OcCoupe wrote:I hope this gives people a little boost of enthusiasm. We all love these cars for very good reasons. Other people that may not have considered the e28 5 years ago are now recognizing how great they really are. Now there's a little payoff for our passions. Now go give your e28 a little love.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 6:23 PM
by topher800
.....
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 6:45 PM
by russellrh72
Nevermind George I changed my mind. You convinced me
Should have posted here for 50k and talked the buyer up to 52k
What an amazing flurry of bidding. I am so happy for both parties. Any effort to keep that car in that condition should be rewarded to the highest degree. Koudos!
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 8:09 PM
by Karl Grau
I think a really nice gesture would be for the seller to take us all out for beers on Friday. Seriously though, congrats to both seller and buyer. You
both can be happy with the transaction.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 8:52 PM
by domenico
I understand how nice the car is .... but it's not even a true 535IS. I guess that doesn't matter in this case. Do you think this will push the prices higher on 88 M5's or M6's? E34 M5's?
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 8:55 PM
by oldskool
domenico wrote:I understand how nice the car is .... but it's not even a true 535IS. I guess that doesn't matter in this case. Do you think this will push the prices higher on 88 M5's or M6's? E34 M5's?
. . . no
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:17 PM
by George Hanson
wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think THIS car would have sold higher if marketed through MyE28....
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:21 PM
by tig
George Hanson wrote:wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think he would have done better marketing it through MyE28....
Troll.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:32 PM
by Karl Grau
cek wrote:George Hanson wrote:wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think he would have done better marketing it through MyE28....
Troll.
100%, and the worst kind.
From the seller in the other thread (emphasis mine): "
Multiple people contacted me directly that had spent well over $100k on BAT auctions in the last year. One over $250K ...$63K of which was on a e30 Alpina. Another had won an auction for a Magnus Walker prepped outlaw 911. None of them knew of this forum".
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:36 PM
by oldskool
cek wrote:George Hanson wrote:wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think he would have done better marketing it through MyE28....
Troll.
You spelled “Dickhead” wrong. . .
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:42 PM
by tcturbo91
Definitely an interesting auction. Goes to show things are worth what something is willing to pay. Also something to note, if you check out the winners bidding history he has been setting the bar price wise for a few different cars in the last few months.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:43 PM
by George Hanson
oldskool wrote:cek wrote:George Hanson wrote:wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think he would have done better marketing it through MyE28....
Troll.
You spelled “Dickhead” wrong. . .
Is this the "heat" some guy was talking about in the other thread?!? LOL...if I didn't know better I'd say you are trying to hurt my feelings?
PS...I altered my post a little bit to reflect THIS car would attract a better price through MyE28 vs. BAT. The seller may have had any number of concerns other than price that were driving his decision.
I want to make it clear, I am pleased for the seller, and in no way questioning him....what I am questioning is, if securing the highest price was the primary goal for THIS beauty, is MyE28 the best venue for the sale? Personally I think it would have been.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 9:47 PM
by George Hanson
Karl Grau wrote:cek wrote:George Hanson wrote:wkohler wrote:So if the last half hour didn't highlight why BaT was the right choice for listing this car, I don't know what anyone could say.
First thing I would say is, congrats to the seller, very pleased for you.
@wkohler, I think he would have done better marketing it through MyE28....
Troll.
100%, and the worst kind.
From the seller in the other thread (emphasis mine): "
Multiple people contacted me directly that had spent well over $100k on BAT auctions in the last year. One over $250K ...$63K of which was on a e30 Alpina. Another had won an auction for a Magnus Walker prepped outlaw 911. None of them knew of this forum".
But they
all would have discovered
this forum once the MyE28 listing for
THIS car appeared as a featured item on BAT.
This never occurred to you did it?
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 10:03 PM
by russellrh72
George, you're wrong.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 10:25 PM
by tig
russellrh72 wrote:George, you're wrong.
No, George, you're a troll. (He knows he's wrong)
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 11:07 PM
by George Hanson
cek wrote:russellrh72 wrote:George, you're wrong.
No, George, you're a troll. (He knows he's wrong)
Wait a minute, I thought you said I was a "dickhead"? Or was that another guy who can't offer up even the slightest modicum of support for his position...
Did you ever stop to think (doubtful) about what you might be missing? What is the single most important factor in any transaction? Care to venture a guess? Or should I say would you like to take a stab in the dark?
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 11:19 PM
by russellrh72
George Hanson wrote:cek wrote:russellrh72 wrote:George, you're wrong.
No, George, you're a troll. (He knows he's wrong)
Wait a minute, I thought you said I was a "dickhead"? Or was that another guy who can't offer up even the slightest modicum of support for his position...
Did you ever stop to think (doubtful) about what you might be missing? What is the single most important factor in any transaction? Care to venture a guess? Or should I say would you like to take a stab in the dark?
George, you keep speaking in cryptic absolutes and asking questions as though you know the answer. It's oddly aggravating. No, I don't want to take a stab in the dark. You're going to be wrong again, trust me.
Re: Lets talk about the nice E28 on BAT
Posted: Dec 04, 2017 11:44 PM
by George Hanson
russellrh72 wrote:George Hanson wrote:cek wrote:russellrh72 wrote:George, you're wrong.
No, George, you're a troll. (He knows he's wrong)
Wait a minute, I thought you said I was a "dickhead"? Or was that another guy who can't offer up even the slightest modicum of support for his position...
Did you ever stop to think (doubtful) about what you might be missing? What is the single most important factor in any transaction? Care to venture a guess? Or should I say would you like to take a stab in the dark?
George, you keep speaking in cryptic absolutes and asking questions as though you know the answer.
***Again, ever stop to think....aaah, never mind.***
It's oddly aggravating.
***You must be getting outside your comfort zone, treat it as a learning experience 
***
No, I don't want to take a stab in the dark.
***What a surprise. Heel boy...***
You're going to be wrong again, trust me.
***You could be right, but it certainly won't be because of any information you provided.***